Q. We are starting a pilot project for tablets in the field. We have three iPads with Broadband deployed already using Citrix-published applications and so far they are working well. Getting ready to use HCSS Heavyjob Mobile as well.

Has anyone deployed a Windows SurfaceTM to the field yet?

 Jim Gaba

A. We have deployed the HP Elite Pad running Windows 8 with good success.

A. Our goal is to replace existing laptops with a single hybrid device rather than have both tablets and laptops.  We are in the process of deploying HP Split13 x2 hybrids to our field and traveling office staff with three-year Accidental Damage Protection plans. We are using Toshiba Dynadock u3.0 docking stations which allow for up to two external monitors if needed as well as ethernet and additional USB connections.  Testing battery life with a Citrix connection via Wi-Fi and the screen at full brightness resulted in eight hours in laptop mode and four hours in tablet mode (with optional i5 processor and 64GB SSD).  Currently the device only comes with Windows 8 Standard so we purchased the Windows 8 Pro Pack.

A. I have an iPad and a Samsung tablet. Six months ago I got an ultrabook (ASUS). Without realizing it a month went by without ever using either tablet. The ultrabook is only 2.9 lbs, Windows 8 pro, 256G SSD, 13.3" HD display, and shaped like an Macbook Air. The instant on and long battery life have been great. Just sayin’... it’s hard to get away from Windows. And, I think the surface is a tweener POS with too small a screen. The Lenovo Yoga 2 comes out in October. I want one!

A. We are rolling out iPads, but the second generation Windows devices are looking pretty awesome. I agree with the Yoga. 

A. We have a couple Lenovo Thinkpad Helix’s which is a detachable tablet laptop hybrid. They are a bit on the expensive side but might be a good fit for those wanting the best of the Windows world in one device.

I agree with Kevin’s assessment of the application market being much stronger and mature for iOS.  A traditional Windows app doesn’t give you the same experience on a tablet that a touch centric app does that’s been developed from the ground up to run on one.  My opinion is that today’s computing is all about the user experience and not without some flaws of its own I’d say Apple is setting that bar. In our organization our field guys have really loved the iPhone and the iPad. There are also a lot more accessories available for the iPad currently to ruggedize them.  

A. I think this will be dictated by the app/software vendors. We use Prolog and Trimble has indicated it is developing the iPad side more heavily going forward. We currently have Windows tablets out in the field but are testing the Prolog Mobile iPad app. It is looking like we will move to the iPad in the end.

A. No question that the iOS devices are very attractive with what they bring to the table today. That being said, with the growing attention and use of iOS devices by all members of the construction team, has anyone put in place a solid management solution for the devices? Windows-based devices are pretty straight forward but it can get a little complex with the others. While there’s the Apple Configurator, Maas360, Good and many other tools like this, what have others, that have deployed the devices, done to manage and control them? It can turn into the wild west and create many problems for support teams if they are not handled carefully.  

We use a blend of tablets both Windows-based (Motion, Panasonic and Surface) and iOS and deploy them based on the end-user need. Those needs drive the solution we put in place. Currently, iOS managed by Configuator and Maas360.  We have to control these carefully so the business tool doesn’t turn into a personal use problem.

Would be very interested to hear feedback on this.

A. The maturity of iOS is a plus. It is unfortunate because MS and its tablet experience is actually more innovative and useful than Apple's or Google's. First to market means control of it. MS had it for years, so it’s interesting to see them play catch up.

A. You should take a look at the Cisco Meraki offering.  The management software is free and works for iOS, Android, Mac and Windows.  They are trying to sell wireless routers (also excellent) but the management software is free and is better than Maas360.

A. The way I look at it, it really has to do with what you can guarantee for apps/applications. 

• iOS (iPad): Currently moderate app support.  Increasing moderately.
• Android (Galaxy): Currently low, increasing to match iOS.
• Windows RT: Currently almost nonexistent and not likely to increase much.
• Windows 8 Pro: Near 100 percent and likely remaining that way, because ALL business applications must run in Windows or they won’t be heavily adopted.

My opinion: iOS, Android and Windows RT are still personal devices with niche business uses.  If you need an all-purpose device, you still have to use a full Windows device.

We are currently testing Windows Surface Pro and Sony Vaio Duos with Clear or Verizon 4G access points.  The response has been very positive.